Nature指数排名和谷歌学术排名哪个准一些？

胖妞

按照自然指数北大都全球top10了，清华浙大都是十多名，顶尖大学？显然差的太远，没人相信。全球学术清华100名，北大浙大200名左右这还差不多，
1 v- `! R4 f$ c: N3 \对比一下
3 z6 g9 `% G: [; k% w7 `9 a" X( C' a0 s2022 Nature指数排行榜
. `4 U& E. O- k3 M! P% R! K/ ?
1 H, v2 E) C( x( p/ X7 A) I
" w+ T5 t& f/ c6 w' C9 K
谷歌2022学术排行榜

6 Y$ R& P/ k; G9 b& i
+ U. c" I# c! u' e

胖妞

哪个更能反应各学校学术水准在世界上的位置？

天乙贵人

哪个榜自己的粉校高就靠谱

胖妞

天乙贵人 发表于 2022-2-7 12:01
  d9 C1 a6 A: \" ^; k哪个榜自己的粉校高就靠谱

: d* I" M' p" a6 @4 I6 {这显然不对

胖妞

静惠田 发表于 2022-2-7 12:06
+ a; U' {+ _6 n. L3 }8 @都不准 都是规模论

6 D5 B" I. E( w  {$ K, J2 e: V8 ^, {" C如何改革？

besthread

路过留个.....
- h+ P* w: t: f6 u
0 x& J0 X# ]/ t6 l

besthread 发表于 2022-2-7 12:45
最新Nature指数排名：20所中国大学位居全球前100强！
2 d9 B7 T$ X/ m6 i7 ?2 j/ ]. F
! D! D- Z7 M- C, u; s, O8 A——————————————

! r# J8 l8 w# f1 G' cAcademic TOP100

#Rank	Institution	Count	Share
1	Harvard University	2513	873.20
2	Stanford University	1505	593.54
3	Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)	1731	490.39
4	University of Chinese Academy of Sciences (UCAS)	2477	478.90
5	Peking University (PKU)	1654	464.67
6	University of Science and Technology of China (USTC)	1253	448.27
7	University of Oxford	1393	430.01
8	Nanjing University (NJU)	983	429.08
9	Tsinghua University	1329	428.61
10	The University of Tokyo (UTokyo)	1148	414.53
11	University of Cambridge	1306	410.13
12	Zhejiang University (ZJU)	930	394.07
13	Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich (ETH Zurich)	1008	372.48
14	University of California, Berkeley (UC Berkeley)	1147	353.98
15	Fudan University	932	351.44
16	University of Michigan (U-M)	902	343.08
17	University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA)	1000	328.99
18	University of California, San Diego (UC San Diego)	962	324.94
19	Shanghai Jiao Tong University (SJTU)	949	324.63
20	Yale University	925	320.35
21	University of Pennsylvania (Penn)	825	309.47
22	Sun Yat-sen University (SYSU)	818	304.91
23	Northwestern University (NU)	686	292.27
24	Columbia University in the City of New York (CU)	905	288.05
25	University of Toronto (U of T)	764	287.06
26	Cornell University	877	284.78
27	Nankai University (NKU)	544	272.70
28	National University of Singapore (NUS)	804	269.95
29	University of Washington (UW)	952	267.14
30	Johns Hopkins University (JHU)	769	260.50
31	California Institute of Technology (Caltech)	766	251.77
32	Princeton University	689	248.83
33	Sichuan University (SCU)	458	248.46
34	Kyoto University	677	245.49
35	Imperial College London (ICL)	918	241.71
36	The University of Chicago (UChicago)	708	239.95
37	Southern University of Science and Technology (SUSTech)	641	234.79
38	Wuhan University (WHU)	513	234.69
39	Soochow University	445	230.10
40	The University of Texas at Austin (UT Austin)	648	227.80
41	Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Lausanne (EPFL)	583	225.76
42	UCL	936	217.86
43	University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC)	581	216.64
44	Washington University in St. Louis (WUSTL)	588	216.64
45	Nanyang Technological University (NTU)	599	212.69
46	Xiamen University (XMU)	421	207.82
47	University of California, San Francisco (UCSF)	607	207.73
48	New York University (NYU)	599	202.16
49	University of Minnesota (UMN)	561	198.25
50	University of Wisconsin-Madison (UW-Madison)	573	191.36
51	Duke University	654	189.39
52	Osaka University	499	188.71
53	Seoul National University (SNU)	483	187.36
54	Shandong University (SDU)	622	185.54
55	The Pennsylvania State University (Penn State)	553	184.19
56	Huazhong University of Science and Technology (HUST)	472	180.44
57	Tianjin University (TJU)	604	178.48
58	Hunan University (HNU)	326	174.40
59	Jilin University (JLU)	348	172.53
60	Ludwig Maximilians University of Munich (LMU)	678	170.51
61	Weizmann Institute of Science (WIS)	409	170.35
62	Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST)	394	170.10
63	University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB)	513	169.76
64	University of California, Davis (UC Davis)	495	162.80
65	University of Colorado Boulder (CU-Boulder)	558	160.58
66	Technical University of Munich (TUM)	649	160.37
67	University of Copenhagen (UCPH)	654	158.89
68	McGill University	542	158.35
69	The University of Queensland (UQ)	468	155.48
70	The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center (UT Southwestern Medical Center)	302	154.76
71	South China University of Technology (SCUT)	334	154.57
72	University of California, Irvine (UCI)	434	150.37
73	Texas A&M University (TAMU)	427	149.62
74	University of New South Wales (UNSW Sydney)	489	149.42
75	Georgia Institute of Technology (Georgia Tech)	450	148.77
76	Tongji University	445	147.42
77	The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (UNC)	436	145.12
78	University of Maryland, College Park (UMCP)	563	145.04
79	Lanzhou University (LZU)	308	144.15
80	The University of British Columbia (UBC)	501	142.53
81	University of Zurich (UZH)	620	142.32
82	University of Münster (WWU)	335	141.90
83	University of Pittsburgh (Pitt)	472	141.42
84	Purdue University	363	138.24
85	Hebrew University of Jerusalem (HUJI)	305	137.25
86	Tohoku University	409	136.90
87	The University of Edinburgh	576	136.03
88	The University of Manchester (UoM)	519	134.63
89	East China Normal University (ECNU)	356	133.01
90	University of Southern California (USC)	376	129.90
91	Tokyo Institute of Technology (Tokyo Tech)	357	129.87
92	Beijing Institute of Technology (BIT)	281	128.24
93	Utrecht University (UU)	562	127.06
94	The Ohio State University (OSU)	425	126.54
95	Monash University	518	126.49
96	Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT)	394	125.28
97	The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST)	430	124.54
98	Nagoya University	370	124.04
99	Zhengzhou University (ZZU)	470	123.44
100	Xi'an Jiaotong University (XJTU)	330	123.20 5 d4 x6 ^, B) W: J& t   @6 M5 t! U$ g, ^4 o. \% V

% N( B, O3 w* i( ]6 e

了解高校

肯定是google学术啊，这个哪里有什么疑问。自然指数指标涉及的学科连理科都不全。

ls01

自然指数反应一下基础学科还行，但是存在单个学科占比过高问题，比如国内学校有很多都是靠化学，化学一科权重就占了一半了，这显然是不合理的，平衡一下学科权重会好一点，谷歌那个是各学科综合情况比自然指数公平一点

胖妞

如此看来谷歌的要强些

seushanghai

自然指数不包含数学 不包含临床医学 不包含计算机以及整个信息类学科 不包含所有工程类学科
8 b* I6 Q1 m) B7 u所以 这些学科强的学校 不用看自然指数 跟你的强项没什么关系 不能代表你

胖妞

奇怪的是

% L8 V! ?4 O7 F5 A8 R! _; s. k& g中国这么多学校进入自然的top10，在自然指数所涉及的这些学科竟然这么强？

congyun

你的母校哪个排名高哪个就准，比如校友会